Ideas and practice

Three pieces to start. Open one to read it.

You cannot plan your way to care · Leading when the outcome can’t be controlled

Some problems are technical. The problem is clear, the answer is known, and an expert can apply it. A broken pump is technical. Many of the problems human services face are not like that. How does a community recover after loss? How does a team stay together under strain? How does a young person find somewhere to belong?

These are adaptive challenges. The answer is not known in advance. It has to be learned by the people who live with it, and it usually asks them to change something they care about. The common mistake is to treat an adaptive challenge as a technical one: write the procedure, add the form, run the training, measure the output. In a complex situation that gives you more activity and the same result.

A machine can be taken apart and fixed one part at a time. A landscape cannot. You have to read it: where water gathers, where it runs, what grows where and why. Then you work with the ground you have, not the ground the plan assumed.

  • Try small. Run experiments that are safe to fail, small enough that if they go wrong nobody is badly hurt.
  • Watch what emerges. Pay attention to what the experiment actually produces, not what the plan said it would.
  • Amplify what helps, dampen what harms.
  • Move authority to where the knowledge is. The people closest to a problem usually know more about it than the people above them.
  • Hold the heat. Change involves loss. People need pace and company, so the strain is enough to learn from and not so much that it breaks them.

There is one exception. In a crisis, act first to make people safe, then go back to listening. Not every moment is a time for experiments.

Leadership, then, is not only a person at the top. It is also a quality of the space between people: who gets listened to, who is allowed to try something, and what happens when they do.

Questions to sit with:

  • What are we managing as a technical problem that is really an adaptive one?
  • What is the smallest safe experiment we could try this month?
  • Who holds the knowledge, and do they hold the authority?
Same story, fourth service · How fragmented services shape a life

An illustration, not a real person’s story.

Picture a woman who needs somewhere safe to live, help for her child at school, and a doctor who knows her history. Each of those is a real service, and many of them are good. Each has its own forms, its own eligibility rules and its own waiting list. And each begins with the same question: so, what happened?

By the fourth service she has told her story four times, to four people, in four different rooms. Every service sees one part of her life. She is the only one who sees all of it, and the only one expected to hold it together.

No one decided this. No one sat down and designed a system in which she tells her story four times. It emerged from many sensible decisions: each service protecting its funding, its risk and its data. Every part makes sense. The whole does not.

Nobody counts that work. Services are measured on whether they met their own targets, not on what it cost her to be the link between them: the time, the travel, the waiting and the retelling.

It also changes how she is read. A missed appointment can look like someone who is not engaging. Another reading is that she was doing the work of four services at once.

More effort inside each service will not fix this, because the problem lives in the spaces between them. The places to push are the rules about who can share what, the flow of information between services, and the question each service is asked to answer: did we meet our targets, or did her life get better?

  • What shifts if we start from her whole life, instead of the edges of each service?
  • Who has to tell the story more than once, and who decided that?
  • Who is holding the pieces together, and are they supported to?
  • What would it take for services to hold the story between them, so she does not have to?
Belonging is voice, resources and choice · What women need, beyond a welcome

Belonging is often described as a feeling. For many women it is also practical. It depends on whether you have a say, whether you have what you need to act on it, and whether you have a real choice.

Voice is being heard where decisions are made, not only invited to speak. Resources are time, money, transport, childcare and a safe place to meet. Without them, a voice is an invitation she cannot accept. Choice is the freedom to say yes, no, not yet, or to leave, without paying a price for it.

Take one away and belonging thins. A woman can be in the room and still not belong in it. She can be asked for her opinion and have no way to get there, or be offered a seat and no way to say no.

Belonging cannot be installed. It emerges when safety, voice, resources and choice are in place. A facilitator can set the conditions and notice what grows. Small things carry weight: a remembered name, a lift arranged, a seat kept.

Some questions to sit with:

  • Who is missing from the room, and what would it take for her to come?
  • What do we ask women to carry before they arrive?
  • Where do women get to celebrate, not only cope?

These pieces draw on sympoiesis (M. Beth Dempster, taken up by Donna Haraway), adaptive leadership (Ronald Heifetz), the Cynefin framework (Dave Snowden), complexity leadership theory (Mary Uhl-Bien, Russ Marion and Bill McKelvey), Donella Meadows’s work on leverage points, and Tyson Yunkaporta’s Sand Talk (2019) on pattern thinking and metaphor. More essays and talks will gather here.

The monthly essay

Latest essays

The first monthly essay is on its way. Subscribe below and it will arrive in your inbox.